Benefits of long-term psychodynamic psychotherapy

 
By Sheryl Kay • Published: February 16th, 2009
Category: Health in a Heartbeat
Play
Play

Remember when Lucy of Peanuts Gang fame would set up shop with her roadside psychiatric stand? Here’s the latest scientific advice, and it won’t cost you five cents: When it comes to reaping real benefits from psychotherapy, longer is better.

Researchers at the University of Giessen [gee-sin—hard “g”] in Germany found that long-term psychotherapy produces far more successful results than more commonly used short-term therapy protocols. In fact, improvement in symptoms is directly related to the number of therapy sessions patients undergo. The results appear in a recent issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association.

The researchers analyzed twenty-three studies of more than a thousand patients that compared long-term psychodynamic therapy… lasting a year or more… to other forms of therapy. Scientists rated target problems, general psychiatric symptoms, personality functioning and social functioning.

After treatment with long-term psychodynamic psychotherapy, patients with complex mental disorders on average responded better than ninety-six percent of the patients in the comparison groups.

Researchers note that multifaceted mental disorders include long-term problems such as depression or anxiety. Psychodynamic therapy, they say, is different than short-term treatments in that it that it puts the focus on the importance of the patient-therapist relationship. This, they propose, may account for the greater success with long-term approaches.

Doctors also say that while the evidence proves long-term approaches do provide more substantial relief, patients shouldn’t shun short-term help if that’s all an insurance company will cover, particularly if the problem is more acute.